10Duke 101 – Understanding the Basics of 10Duke Licensing20th August 2021
Software Licensing System – The Build vs. Buy Conundrum11th April 2022
Licensing As a Service – Why It’s the Modern Way of Software Licensing
Licensing as a Service (LaaS) can offer software vendors many advantages over developing a licensing engine in-house. The aim of this blog post is to develop an understanding why the concept of software Licensing as a Service has emerged, and why it is worth considering for any software company.
Licensing as a Service enables you to support a wide variety of license models and application types and allows you immediate access to a best-of-breed solution that you pay for either monthly or based on what you use.
License Management as a Service could overcome many, if not all, of the limitations created by more traditional licensing methods such as dongles. Software Licensing as a Service also offers software publishers more flexible and effective means of monetizing their software products quickly and easily.
Software Licensing - How Did We Get Here?
To understand the advantages of Licensing as a Service, a bit of background to software licensing in general is needed. If you're already familiar with it, feel free to skip ahead a couple of chapters.
If you are an independent software vendor (ISV) or a software publisher you will most likely want to monetize the software application you have developed.
The terms under which you provide your software to a customer are defined by the software license - how much the customer has to pay, for how long, which versions of your application does their license apply to, etc.
Historically, a lot of software products were licensed on a perpetual license under which the customer paid once, but then could pay an option annual maintenance fee to continue to receive newer versions of the application, bug fixes and perhaps some support. As more and more software is being provided online, there has been a shift away from the limitations of perpetual software licensing to much more sophisticated licensing models that can be better suited to the software product being sold.
In order to overcome the limitation of traditional software licensing services and to capitalise on the opportunities created for software publishers by the Internet, a new method of software licensing has emerged called Licensing as a Service (LaaS).
What Are the Traditional Methods For Licensing Software?
The simplest way to license software is to have a written paper license agreement between the software vendor and the customer. The vendor would then trust that the customer will comply with the terms of the software license and, normally, the software license would contain some right of audit, under which the vendor could do an occasional 'spot check' to ensure that the customer was using the software in a manner consistent with the agreed software license.
The obvious drawbacks of such an approach include a lack of scalability (paper contracts are slow to process), significant room for abuse (it's tricky to audit a customer without irritating them) and if the software was distributed, it is impossible to limit unauthorised use by anyone who manages to get a copy.
In order to address these issues, software vendors turned to a digital solution called a dongle. Dongles (known as license dongles or keys) are electronic / hardware-based protection locks initially introduced by software businesses to protect and prevent unauthorised usage or unwanted distribution of their high-value software applications (normally desktop apps).
The dongle's firmware is integrated with the software of the application and contains information used to authorise access - what and how can the end-user use the software. The user can get access to the software application only if the dongle is physically present on the computer.
While in theory dongles seemed to work well, they turned out to have significant limitations - someone had to keep track of them being issued and returned, they broke and had to be replaced, there were hardware compatibility issues and they could be easily transferred between people in the same company so they didn't prevent software abuse within a customer site.
For more information on the limitations of license dongles, click here.
What Is Licensing as a Service (LaaS)?
When a software vendor uses a Licensing as a Service solution the vendor is choosing to focus on their area of expertise - creating the software application - and they are in effect outsourcing the responsibility of enforcing the license terms of the software license to the Licensing as a Service provider.
This means they don't have to worry about licensing in-house or having to develop licensing features on top of the core software application. The software developer remains in complete control of the terms under which their software is licensed and the Licensing as a Service provider enables them to enforce those terms with the end customer.
So What Are The New Capabilities Offered By a Software Licensing as a Service Provider?
Software Licensing companies who provide License Management as a Service will typically offer many of the same capabilities offered by any Software as a Service (SaaS) provider - but with specific reference to the aspects of licensing software. This includes general SaaS features like cloud-based delivery, global coverage, monthly or consumption-based billing, and web-based configuration.
In addition, Licensing as a Service providers will typically enable features such as selecting and enabling the correct license model for the software product and enforcement of the specific license terms under which the customer has licensed the software application. A Licensing as a Service provider will provide a ready-to-go licensing engine that simply needs to be configured to suit the software products or product suite of the software vendor before being deployed.
What License Models Are Supported?
One of the big advantages of working with a licensing specialist is that they will typically support a wide variety of license models. This means that the software vendor can simply select the license model best suited to their product and customer base, such as the number of end users, the price paid, time elapsed, and geographic locations in which the software can be used.
While the current trend is to deploy subscription-based license models, not all software products are best sold on a subscription basis and a Licensing as a Service provider can facilitate alternative models that enable a software product to be monetized more effectively. This is particularly the case in a business to business context as well as large-scale consumer offerings.
Some example license models that a typical License as a Service provider can offer includes common models such as perpetual and subscription, but also more complex models such as floating licenses, corporate on-demand licenses, offline usage (a license model well-suited for the construction or mining industries), aggregate use time licenses, concurrent usage, and more.
For a full list of license models with detailed explanations, click here.
How Do You Work With a Licensing as a Service Provider?
The whole point of working with Software Licensing companies is that software vendors can focus on their application and let the LaaS provider take care of licensing.
In practice, this normally involves a small integration between the application and the License as a Service provider's engine, an integration to a 3rd party payment provider such as Stripe or Braintree if the software vendor wants to accept online payments, an integration to the CRM or ERP system in order to keep customer information in sync for the vendor and that's pretty much it. The new licensing solution is then typically deployed to software vendor's existing customers at the next application update or immediately for new customers.
What Advantages Come From Using a Licensing as a Service Provider?
● Access to a best of breed licensing solution that just has to be configured and integrated rather than developed from scratch, saving time and money
● Access to license models that the software vendor may not have thought of or considered for their software product that may help to better monetize it
● Access to better features that may allow the vendor to offer their software product on terms best suited to their customers such as concurrent usage, license by feature, and self-serve license purchase and renewal
● Immediate global coverage if needed
● Better IP protection and license enforcement
● Time-savings, allowing the deployment of new license models quickly, rather than the software vendor having to develop, debug, and test 3rd party integrations to CRM, ERP and payment providers. This is key, particularly in regard to payment providers. If the software vendor needs to switch, they won't have to do the (re)integration.
● Support - most LaaS providers will offer comprehensive support packages which the vendor can access if and when needed
Working with a Licensing as a Service (LaaS) provider can offer software vendors many advantages over developing a licensing engine in-house. These range from being able to support a wide variety of license models and application types to getting immediate access to a best-of-breed solution that you pay for monthly or based on what you use.
LaaS providers are able to overcome many, if not all, of the limitations created by more traditional licensing methods such as dongles and offer software publishers a more flexible and effective means of monetizing their software products quickly and easily.
Click here for further information on the Licensing As a Service solution offered by 10Duke.
Understand the basics of 10Duke Licensing with a 10Duke 101.
Are you a software developer looking to sell more? Learn more from our guides:
Should You Build Your Own Licensing System or Buy It From a Specialist?
Software Monetization Guide – How to Monetize Software?
Software Licensing Guide – Why is it so important?
Why Software Companies Should Consider the Subscription Business Model
What is a Software License Manager? [Guide]
Software Licensing Solutions – Guide
Software Licensing Models – Ultimate Guide to Software License Types
Customer Identity and Access Management – What should a good CIAM solution provide?
You might also be interested in:
Licensing as a Service, a new method of software licensing, offers flexible and effective means of monetizing software products quickly and easily.